Under California’s net billing tariff, the rules widely called NEM 3.0, an exported kWh usually earns far less than a kWh bought back from the grid, so the value of solar depends on where each kWh goes. The order that pays is: use solar in the house as it is produced, move flexible loads into sunny hours, store surplus for the 4 to 9 p.m. peak, and export what is left, or export on purpose in the few summer evening hours when the hourly export credit beats the import price. When buying, size the system to what the house and a battery can absorb, not to annual kWh.
The same order works under any tariff where exports earn less than imports, from Kentucky’s NMS-2 credit to zero-export programs. This article uses PG&E’s published import prices and export credit sheets as the reference case, then applies the logic elsewhere. Definitions of net metering and net billing, and how each credits exports, are covered in net metering vs net billing.
What changed under NEM 3.0
NEM 3.0 is the informal name for California’s net billing tariff (NBT). It credits exported solar at values tied to what the utility avoids by not buying that energy elsewhere, instead of at the retail price, and it requires a time-of-use rate.
The California Public Utilities Commission adopted decision D.22-12-056 on December 15, 2022, “establishing the Net Billing tariff (NBT) as a successor to NEM2,” according to the CPUC’s net billing tariff page. The CPUC’s net energy metering and net billing page says that “since April 15, 2023, customers applying for interconnection have taken service on the new net billing tariff.” In Resolution E-5301 on November 30, 2023, the CPUC established the net billing tariff with minor modifications.
| Feature | Net billing tariff (PG&E, SCE and SDG&E) |
|---|---|
| Who it applies to | Customers whose interconnection application went in on or after April 15, 2023 |
| What an export earns | “CPUC Avoided Cost Calculator values (usually lower than import rates)” |
| Rate plan | A required time-of-use rate: E-ELEC at PG&E, TOU-D-PRIME at SCE, EV-TOU-5 at SDG&E |
| Billing | Payment is due monthly; excess credits roll over until the annual true-up |
| How long | The original NBT customer keeps NBT service for nine years, per the CPUC |
| Extra credit | Residential PG&E and SCE customers who apply before the end of 2027 receive “slightly higher-than-normal bill credits for exported energy for nine years”; SDG&E customers are excluded |
| Batteries | The CPUC credits “the nearly 70 percent of net billing tariff (NBT) customers who paired batteries with their solar by the end of 2024” with reducing the need for gas plants |
The table’s quotes and terms come from the CPUC’s net energy metering and net billing page, checked November 2026. PG&E calls the extra credit Energy Export Bonus Credits, available to customers who “adopt solar and start on Solar Billing Plan before 2028,” and PG&E calls its version of the tariff the Solar Billing Plan.
Why the change? The CPUC’s November 2022 fact sheet on the proposed decision said the new structure would “incentivize solar exports during the late afternoon and early evening hours, particularly in the summer, when the grid is the most stressed,” and noted that greenhouse gas emissions are highest between 4 and 9 p.m. In other words, the tariff pays for timing.
How export credits are set, hour by hour
Under net billing, an exported kWh is worth what your utility’s export credit sheet says for that hour, day type and month. Those values come from the CPUC’s Avoided Cost Calculator, and on PG&E’s 2026 sheet they swing from zero in spring middays to about a dollar on some summer evenings.
The Avoided Cost Calculator
The Avoided Cost Calculator (ACC) is the CPUC’s model of what a utility avoids when a customer’s equipment supplies or saves energy. The CPUC says it calculates avoided generation capacity, energy, ancillary services, greenhouse gas emissions, transmission and distribution capacity and other costs. It was established in 2005 and is updated every two years; the 2026 update was adopted in Resolution E-5476 on October 8, 2026.
You do not need to run the model. What matters is its shape: energy is cheap to avoid in midday hours when solar output is high, and expensive to avoid in the evening as solar fades.
What PG&E’s credit sheets show
PG&E’s Solar Billing Plan page says the export credit “will vary by time of day, day of the week and season.” PG&E publishes a price sheet for each interconnection application year in its Energy Export Credit price sheets, and its how-to sheet tells customers to use the sheet “for the year you submitted your interconnection application.” For the Energy Export Bonus Credits, PG&E notes that the “credit value is set when your system receives permission to operate.”
Each credit has two parts. Energy Produced is the generation value, and Energy Delivered is the delivery value. PG&E’s sheet says Energy Produced credits apply only to customers who buy their generation from PG&E; customers of a community choice aggregator should ask that provider for its generation export pricing.
The color key on PG&E’s 2026 sheet shows the spread:
| Band on the 2026 sheet | Energy Produced, per kWh | Energy Delivered, per kWh |
|---|---|---|
| Highest value for credits | $0.09930 to $0.99821 | $0.00203 to $0.35038 |
| Higher value | $0.06560 to $0.09929 | $0.00136 to $0.00202 |
| Average value | $0.03280 to $0.06559 | $0.00068 to $0.00135 |
| Lower value | $0.00000 to $0.03279 | $0.00001 to $0.00067 |
On that sheet, the zero and near-zero values sit in spring midday hours, and the values near a dollar sit in summer evening hours. That matches the CPUC’s own summary: export credits are usually lower than import rates but “can rise above the retail rate on late summer evenings.”
One hour, worked through
PG&E’s how-to sheet walks through a single hour: 7.02 kWh exported between 1 and 2 p.m. on an October weekday, on a sheet showing $0.04783 per kWh for Energy Produced and $0.00781 for Energy Delivered. The arithmetic is 7.02 x ($0.04783 + $0.00781) = 7.02 x $0.05564 = $0.39. PG&E’s sheet shows $0.38, because it cuts each part to the cent ($0.33 plus $0.05).
So 7 kWh of afternoon surplus earned under 40 cents. Buying the same amount back at the current winter-season peak price on PG&E’s E-ELEC rate, described below, would cost 7.02 x $0.32063 = $2.25.
What a surplus kWh is worth: use, store or export
Every kWh of solar surplus has three possible uses, and under a low export credit their values are far apart. Using it in the house saves the import price in that hour; storing it saves the price in a later hour, less battery losses; exporting it earns the credit.
The import prices on PG&E’s required rate
Residential customers on the net billing tariff must be served on PG&E’s Electric Schedule E-ELEC (Electric Home), whose tariff states that NBT residential customers “must be served under this schedule.” Its time periods are the same every day, weekends and holidays included: peak 4 to 9 p.m., partial-peak 3 to 4 p.m. and 9 p.m. to midnight, and off-peak all other hours. Summer runs June 1 to September 30 and winter October 1 to May 31.
| E-ELEC total bundled energy rate | Peak (4 to 9 p.m.) | Partial-peak | Off-peak |
|---|---|---|---|
| Summer (June to September) | $0.55214 | $0.39026 | $0.33358 |
| Winter (October to May) | $0.32063 | $0.29854 | $0.28468 |
These are PG&E’s total bundled energy rates per kWh on E-ELEC Sheet 2 (Cal. P.U.C. Sheet No. 61363-E), effective June 1, 2026, before taxes. The schedule also has a daily base services charge that depends on income tier ($0.79343 a day for customers in neither assistance tier), and it calculates charges differently for customers of a community choice aggregator.
The chart makes the problem plain. In a spring midday hour, a kWh exported may earn a cent or less, while the same kWh bought back at 6 p.m. costs 32 cents in winter season and 55 cents in summer.
The value of one surplus kWh, side by side
To compare uses, put each one in cents per kWh of solar surplus. Battery storage loses energy on the way in and out; NREL’s Annual Technology Baseline adopts 85% as a representative round-trip efficiency for residential batteries, so a stored kWh returns 0.85 kWh later.
| Use of one surplus kWh at noon | PG&E E-ELEC, summer | PG&E E-ELEC, winter season | LG&E RTOD-Energy, April to October | LG&E Rate RS (flat) with NMS-2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Runs a load moved out of the peak window | 55.2 cents | 32.1 cents | 19.3 cents | 11.5 cents (any hour) |
| Stored and used in the peak window (x 0.85) | 46.9 cents | 27.3 cents | 16.4 cents | 9.8 cents |
| Runs a load moved out of off-peak hours | 33.4 cents | 28.5 cents | 9.3 cents | 11.5 cents |
| Exported | Your hourly credit (see your sheet) | Your hourly credit; spring middays sit in the lowest band, 0 to 3.3 cents | 7.1 cents | 7.1 cents |
Four lessons come out of that table:
- Moving a load out of the peak beats storing for the peak by the battery’s losses, 15% of the peak price. A water heater that runs at noon instead of 6 p.m. is a battery with no round-trip loss.
- Storing beats exporting whenever the midday credit is below the stored value: 46.9 cents in a PG&E summer and 27.3 cents in the winter season, against spring midday credits in the sheet’s lowest band of 0 to 3.3 cents. In Kentucky the margin is smaller but still positive.
- The order between storing and moving an off-peak load depends on the season. In a PG&E summer, storing for the peak (46.9 cents) beats moving an overnight load into solar hours (33.4 cents). In the winter season the two are close (27.3 against 28.5 cents).
- On a flat rate with a moderate credit, a battery adds little for self-consumption. At LG&E Rate RS, storing is worth 9.8 cents against 7.1 cents for exporting, a gain of 2.7 cents per kWh.
The decision order when exports earn less
When the export credit is well below the import price, the schedule should work down a fixed list for every hour of surplus. The list below is the order that the values in the previous section produce.
- Cover the house as the panels produce. Every kWh used as it is made avoids a purchase in that hour at full price.
- Move flexible loads out of the peak and into solar hours. This beats any battery, because nothing is lost in storage.
- Charge the battery from surplus for the evening peak. Charge until the battery holds what the peak needs, plus the outage reserve you choose.
- Move loads from off-peak hours into solar hours when storage is full or worth less. In PG&E’s winter season this is roughly as valuable as storing.
- Export the rest. It is the lowest-value use of a midday kWh, but any credit above zero is better than holding the panels back for nothing.
- Export on purpose when the credit beats the import price. On some summer evenings, PG&E’s credits rise above the retail rate. Whether a battery may discharge to the grid, and how those exports are metered, is set by your interconnection agreement and equipment, so confirm it first.
- Never plan below the outage reserve. The reserve is the part of the battery that is not for sale or for the peak.
What changes on weekends, in winter and on cloudy days
The order stays the same through the year, but the amount of surplus it has to work with does not. On PG&E’s E-ELEC rate the peak runs from 4 to 9 p.m. every day, weekends included, so the battery’s evening job never takes a day off. PG&E’s export credit sheets, on the other hand, list separate values for weekdays and weekends, so the same exported kWh can earn a different credit on a Saturday.
In winter, and on cloudy days in any season, the panels may produce little or no surplus after covering the house. Then the first three steps use everything: the house takes what it needs, and whatever is left goes into the battery for the peak. Moving loads into solar hours matters less on those days, and grid charging becomes the question, which is covered below.
On the sunniest spring days the opposite happens. The battery fills before noon, the flexible loads have run, and the rest is exported in the hours when PG&E’s sheet pays least. Those are the days that show whether the system is sized for the house or for the roof.
Culni’s solar export feature applies this kind of order hour by hour from a home’s decoded rate and export credit. It does not change the credit, the tariff or any interconnection or inverter export settings.
Example (fictional). The site’s example home uses an example rate, not a real tariff: 8 cents off-peak (9 p.m. to 7 a.m.), 14 cents in the day (7 a.m. to 4 p.m.), 31 cents at the peak (4 to 9 p.m.) and a 7 cent export credit. On a clear April weekday, with the battery in its default self-use mode, the home buys 18.3 kWh ($3.41), exports 12.7 kWh ($0.89 credit) and nets $2.52. With a schedule that charges the car overnight and holds the battery for the peak, it buys 21.0 kWh ($1.71), exports 15.9 kWh ($1.12) and nets $0.60, a difference of $1.92.
Now suppose the export credit were 2 cents instead of 7, to mimic a low-export tariff, with everything else unchanged. Default: 12.7 x $0.02 = $0.25 credit, so $3.41 - $0.25 = $3.16. Scheduled: 15.9 x $0.02 = $0.32 credit, so $1.71 - $0.32 = $1.39. The difference narrows to $3.16 - $1.39 = $1.77.
Two things stand out. Most of the schedule’s value comes from not buying 8.4 kWh at the 31 cent peak (8.4 x $0.31 = $2.60), and a lower credit does not touch that. And the scheduled day exports more, because the battery fills by about 11 a.m. and then holds; at 2 cents, those 15.9 kWh are worth only $0.32, so the next gain is finding daytime uses for them.
One clear spring weekday is not a month or a year. Cloudy days, winter, weekends and a real tariff change the result, and a real plan models each day type.
Flexible loads: the storage you already own
Loads that can run at any time within a window are worth more under net billing than under net metering, because each kWh they move into solar hours is a kWh that would otherwise have been exported for little. Start with the largest loads that do not care exactly when they run.
The loads worth moving
- Heat pump water heater. Heating the tank at midday stores heat instead of electricity, with no battery loss. A tank heated to a higher setpoint in the early afternoon may carry the household’s hot water through the evening peak, depending on tank size and use.
- Pool pump. Its daily run hours can sit entirely inside the sunniest part of the day.
- Pre-cooling. On a hot afternoon, cooling the house a few degrees before 4 p.m., within the comfort range you set, moves part of the evening air conditioning load into solar hours.
- Laundry and the dishwasher. Started on a delay timer, they run on surplus instead of at the peak.
- An EV that is home during the day. A car plugged in at noon on a weekend or a work-from-home day can absorb several kW of surplus while it charges. A car that leaves at 7:30 a.m. and returns at 6 p.m. cannot.
The details of timing each appliance are covered on the flexible loads page.
What one moved kWh is worth
The arithmetic is short. A kWh moved from the PG&E summer peak into a surplus hour saves $0.55214 at the peak and gives up the export credit. Suppose that hour’s credit is 2 cents (a hypothetical value within the sheet’s lower bands): the move is worth $0.55214 - $0.02 = about 53 cents. Storing the same kWh in a battery for the peak would be worth 0.85 x $0.55214 - $0.02 = about 45 cents.
The site’s solar self-consumption calculator shows the same effect at monthly scale. Its default example has 900 kWh of solar a month, 40% used at home, a 13 cent retail price and a 7 cent credit. Raising the share used at home to 60% moves 180 kWh from export to self-use: 180 x ($0.13 - $0.07) = $10.80 a month. With a 2 cent credit instead, the same move is worth 180 x ($0.13 - $0.02) = $19.80 a month. The lower the credit, the more every moved kWh is worth.
Batteries under net billing: what they fix and what they do not
A battery turns cheap midday surplus into expensive evening energy, which is exactly what a low export credit rewards. It does not fix a system that is far too large for the house, and its value depends on the gap between the peak price and the credit, after losses.
Why most new NBT systems include one
The CPUC reports that nearly 70% of net billing customers paired batteries with their solar by the end of 2024. The prices explain why: in a PG&E summer, a stored kWh is worth 46.9 cents at the peak, and the same kWh exported at midday may earn a few cents or less.
Size the battery to the evening, not the roof
The useful battery size is set by the energy the house uses in the peak window, plus the reserve you keep for outages, not by the size of the array. A battery larger than the evening need fills early and then holds energy that has nowhere valuable to go until the next evening.
Example (fictional). The example home uses 9.9 kWh between 4 and 9 p.m. on its clear April weekday (1.4 + 2.0 + 2.4 + 2.2 + 1.9 kWh in those five hours). Its 13.5 kWh battery keeps a 20% reserve of 2.7 kWh, leaving 10.8 kWh for daily use, which covers that evening. At 85% round-trip efficiency, delivering 9.9 kWh to the house takes about 9.9 / 0.85 = 11.6 kWh of solar charged in. On that day the panels make 36.3 kWh, so finding the surplus is not the constraint; the battery’s size and the peak window are.
Grid charging is a separate question
Under net billing, charging a battery from the grid overnight can pay in one season and lose in another. On PG&E’s E-ELEC rate in summer, a kWh bought off-peak at $0.33358 returns 0.85 kWh at the peak, worth 0.85 x $0.55214 = $0.46932, a gain of about 13.6 cents per kWh bought. In the winter season, the same trade returns 0.85 x $0.32063 = $0.27254 for $0.28468 spent, a loss of about 1.2 cents.
Whether your battery may charge from the grid at all, and what that does to how its exports are treated, depends on the equipment and your interconnection agreement. When grid charging a battery pays works through those rules and the warranty side of daily cycling.
Reserve, warranties and limits
Every kWh held for an outage is a kWh that cannot cover the peak. A battery cycled every day also uses up its warranty throughput faster than one held for backup. Both trade-offs belong in the plan, and Culni’s battery scheduling and battery homes pages describe how a schedule weighs them for solar plus storage.
Sizing a new system for self-consumption, not annual kWh
Under one-for-one net metering, a system sized to produce a year’s worth of the home’s use made sense, because each exported kWh offset a purchased kWh at or near the retail price. Under net billing, panels beyond what the house and battery can absorb add mostly low-value exports.
Why the last kW is worth less
Suppose an extra 1 kW of panels adds 4 kWh on a clear spring day (a hypothetical figure), all of it surplus exported in midday hours that sit in PG&E’s lowest band, 0 to 3.3 cents per kWh. That extra production earns at most 4 x $0.033 = about 13 cents that day. If the house could use the same 4 kWh in place of winter-season off-peak purchases, they would be worth 4 x $0.28468 = $1.14.
The first kW of panels mostly covers daytime use and charges the battery; the last kW mostly exports. That is why a system sized to annual kWh can produce plenty and still disappoint.
A sizing procedure
- Get your hourly usage. PG&E’s Energy Usage Details page shows imports and exports by hour in its Day View; other utilities may offer similar downloads.
- Find your daytime use by season. Add up the kWh used while the sun is producing on typical summer and winter days.
- Add the battery’s daily charge. Use the evening peak need plus the reserve, as in the example above.
- Add loads you can move or plan to add. A heat pump water heater, an EV at home on some days, a heat pump.
- Size the array to cover that total on a typical day, not on the sunniest day and not to the annual total.
- Consider orientation. Panels facing west shift production later into the afternoon, closer to the peak window; ask the installer to model that hourly trade-off against a south-facing layout.
- Run the comparison with your own rate and credit sheet, not a rule of thumb.
Is solar worth it under NEM 3.0?
It can be, but the answer now depends on how much of the production the home uses or stores, not on how much it produces. A quote that does not show the share of production it expects you to export, and the credit it assumes for those exports, cannot answer the question.
Why published payback figures disagree
Payback estimates for the same California home can differ a lot because they rest on different assumptions, and those assumptions are not always printed next to the result. The biggest ones are the share of production exported, the export credit assumed for it, the import rate and how fast it is assumed to rise, the battery’s round-trip efficiency and the daily cycling assumed.
Figures published before 2026 may also include the federal Residential Clean Energy Credit. The IRS says that credit was 30% of qualified costs for property installed from 2022 through 2025, and that it “is not available for any property placed in service after December 31, 2025.” Any payback that still counts it does not apply to a system installed now.
What to ask for in a quote
- Hourly or monthly production, with the share expected to be exported. A single annual kWh figure hides the problem.
- The export credit values used. Ask which year’s sheet they come from and whether they assume PG&E generation service or a community choice aggregator.
- The import rate used, with its time periods, and any assumption about future increases, stated as a number.
- The battery assumptions: usable kWh, round-trip efficiency, the reserve kept for outages and how many cycles a year.
- Whether bonus export credits are included, and for how many years.
- What happens if you use less or more electricity, for example after adding an EV or a heat pump.
With those inputs printed, two quotes become comparable, and you can check each against your own hourly data rather than taking the result on trust.
Outside California: the same logic under other low-export rules
The decision order does not depend on California. Any tariff that pays less for an exported kWh than it charges for an imported one rewards the same moves, in proportion to the gap.
Kentucky’s NMS-2 credit
In Kentucky, Louisville Gas and Electric (LG&E) credits exports from systems first in service on or after September 24, 2021, up to 45 kW, under Rider NMS-2. Its tariff (P.S.C. Electric No. 14, Sheet No. 58, effective February 16, 2026) bills “all energy consumed” at the customer’s standard rate and gives “a dollar denominated bill credit for each kWh Customer produces to the Company’s grid” of $0.07089 per kWh. The credit applies only to the energy charge and per-kWh riders, unused credits carry forward, and credits remaining when service ends end with the account.
Against LG&E’s Rate RS energy charge of $0.11499 per kWh (Sheet No. 5, effective September 1, 2026, base charge before riders and taxes), a kWh used at home is worth $0.11499 - $0.07089 = $0.0441 more than the same kWh exported. The gap is far smaller than in California, so a battery adds little on a flat rate, as the table above shows. On LG&E’s optional RTOD-Energy rate (on-peak $0.19307, off-peak $0.09312 per kWh, Sheet No. 6, effective September 1, 2026), storing for the on-peak window is worth 16.4 cents against a 7.1 cent credit.
Kentucky’s on-peak windows differ from California’s. RTOD-Energy’s rating periods, set in Eastern Standard Time on Sheet No. 6.1, put the April to October weekday on-peak at 1 to 5 p.m., while panels are still producing, and the November to March weekday on-peak at 6 to 10 a.m. and 6 to 10 p.m. Older systems in service before September 24, 2021 stay on NMS-1 with kWh credits until LG&E ends that rider on September 24, 2046. The full Kentucky picture is in Kentucky net metering.
Zero-export interconnections
Some programs pay nothing for exports because they do not allow them. Hawaiian Electric’s Smart Renewable Energy Non-Export option “enables customers to use renewable systems such as rooftop solar that do not export power to the utility grid.” Power the customer generates must be used as it is produced or stored for later, the systems “can incorporate the use of energy storage devices, like batteries,” and participants must have advanced meters.
Under a zero-export rule the decision order loses its last step: there is no export, so surplus the house and battery cannot absorb is simply not produced. Sizing to self-consumption stops being an optimization and becomes the design rule.
How to read any low-export tariff
Three numbers decide the strategy, wherever you live:
| What to find | Where it is | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Import price by hour and season | Your rate schedule’s energy charges and time periods | What a kWh used at home saves in each hour |
| Export value by hour, or a flat credit | Your net metering or net billing rider, or the utility’s export price sheet | What a kWh sent to the grid earns |
| Battery round-trip efficiency | The battery’s specification sheet, or 85% as a representative value | How much of a stored kWh comes back |
If the export value is close to the import price, as under one-for-one net metering, timing matters little. The wider the gap, the more each step of the decision order is worth.
Checking the result on your bill
Under net billing, the monthly statement is where you see whether the plan worked. Look at exports by hour, not just the monthly total, because the same kWh can be worth a dollar or nothing depending on when it left the house.
PG&E says a Solar Billing Plan customer receives a monthly energy statement showing credits for solar energy produced and delivered to the grid, charges for energy PG&E supplies when the system falls short, additional credits such as the Energy Export Bonus Credits, and taxes and other charges. At the end of the 12-month cycle, a True-Up Statement summarizes the year’s charges and credits, and PG&E notes that some true-up cycles may be shorter than a year.
To check one day yourself, PG&E’s how-to sheet says to open Energy Usage Details, choose Day View, read the kWh exported in each hour and multiply each by the matching value on your sheet. A month of that by hand is tedious, but a few sample days in spring and summer will show whether your exports are landing in the cheap hours or the valuable ones.
A schedule can do the same comparison every month. Culni’s monthly bill check compares the estimate with the actual bill and explains what moved.
What to do next
Start from your own numbers. The order of use, store and export is the same everywhere; the cents attached to each step are what you need to find.
- Find your export values. In California, download your utility’s credit sheet for your interconnection application year; in Kentucky, note your NMS-1 or NMS-2 rider and the credit on your bill.
- Find your import prices by hour. Your rate schedule lists the windows and prices; the rate engine page explains what a schedule reads from it.
- Compare a kWh used against a kWh exported. The solar self-consumption calculator shows what raising the share used at home is worth.
- Compare the two credit designs. The net metering credit calculator puts a month of imports and exports under net metering and net billing side by side.
- List the loads that can move, starting with the water heater, the pool pump and any EV that is home during the day.
- If you are buying, size the system to daytime use plus the battery’s evening charge, and ask the installer to show the hourly export estimate, not only the annual production figure.
Culni is home energy software that reads a home’s electricity rate and export credit and runs one daily schedule across solar, a battery, EV charging and flexible loads, then checks the result against the bill each month. If you want that order worked out for your own rate and equipment, you can send your rate plan, a recent bill and your device list through the contact page.
