Net metering and net billing are two ways a utility credits the solar electricity you send to the grid. Under net metering, each kWh you export cancels a kWh you buy, so an exported kWh is worth about the retail price. Under net billing, the utility bills every kWh you buy at the retail price and pays a separate, usually lower credit for every kWh you export, so a kWh you use at home is worth more than a kWh you export.
The names are not used consistently, so read the tariff rather than the label. Kentucky’s statute calls its dollar-credit design “net metering”, while California’s regulator calls a similar idea “net billing”. What actually sets the value of an export is five settings inside the tariff: the netting interval, the credit rate, what the credit may offset, how leftover credit carries over, and which charges you pay regardless of exports. This article explains each setting, then reads three real designs: California’s net billing tariff and the NMS-1 and NMS-2 riders at LG&E and KU in Kentucky, with tariffs checked on November 22, 2026.
Net metering and net billing side by side
The short version is that net metering nets kWh and net billing nets dollars. Four definitions make the rest of this article easier to follow:
- Net metering: a billing arrangement in which the kWh you export offset the kWh you import over a set period, usually the billing month, so exports are credited at the retail energy price.
- Net billing: a billing arrangement in which imports and exports are counted separately; imports are billed at the retail rate and exports earn a credit set by a separate price or formula.
- Export credit: what the utility gives you for each exported kWh, either as a kWh credit or as a dollar amount on the bill.
- True-up: the date on which leftover credits are settled, paid out at a lower price or forfeited.
| Net metering | Net billing | |
|---|---|---|
| What is netted | kWh in against kWh out | Dollars: the cost of imports against the value of exports |
| Typical netting interval | The billing period, sometimes a year | Each metered interval, or every kWh as it flows |
| Value of an exported kWh | About the retail energy price | A separate credit: a fixed avoided-cost price or prices that vary by hour |
| Value of a kWh used at home | The retail price | The retail price |
| Difference between using and exporting a kWh | Small | The full gap between the retail price and the export credit |
| Where a battery earns its keep | Backup, or arbitrage on a time-of-use rate | Moving daytime surplus into evening hours |
| Examples checked November 2026 | California NEM 1.0 and NEM 2.0 (closed to new customers); NMS-1 at LG&E and KU | California’s net billing tariff; NMS-2 at LG&E and KU |
One thing is the same under both designs: solar the house uses as it is produced never reaches the utility meter. LG&E and KU’s net metering page puts it plainly: “Generation does not equal credit.” The net meter “records only the energy you produce that flows onto” the grid, so your inverter app will always show more production than your bill shows exports. The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) says the same of its tariff: onsite generation “is first used to serve onsite load” before anything is exported, as its key information page explains.
So the whole comparison is about the surplus. Net metering and net billing value the kWh you use at home identically. They differ only in what the leftover kWh are worth and when they are counted.
The five settings that decide what an exported kWh is worth
Every net metering or net billing tariff answers five questions, and together the answers set the value of an export. Two tariffs with the same name can answer them differently, and two tariffs with different names can answer them almost the same way.
1. The netting interval
The netting interval is the stretch of time over which kWh flowing in and out are added up before anything is priced. It can be a billing month, an hour, or no interval at all, in which case the meter simply records every kWh that flows each way as it happens. The longer the interval, the more of your daytime exports can cancel evening imports at the retail price.
Even California’s older net metering tariffs used a short interval for part of the bill. Under NEM 2.0, the CPUC’s comparison table shows that non-bypassable charges were calculated on net energy consumed in each metered interval: one hour for residential customers and 15 minutes for nonresidential ones. Under the current net billing tariff, those charges apply to all energy imports.
2. The credit rate
The credit rate is what one exported kWh earns. There are three common designs:
- Retail, kWh for kWh. An exported kWh cancels a purchased kWh, so it is worth whatever that purchased kWh would have cost.
- A fixed dollar credit. Each exported kWh earns a set amount, often built from the utility’s avoided costs. LG&E’s NMS-2 credit is $0.07089 per kWh and KU’s is $0.07534 (tariff Sheet No. 58, effective February 16, 2026).
- Time-varying export prices. Each exported kWh earns the price for its hour, month and day type. California’s net billing tariff works this way.
Avoided cost is the cost a utility does not incur because your exported kWh replaced energy, capacity or grid use it would otherwise have produced or bought. It is almost always below the retail price, because the retail price also pays for poles, wires, meters, billing and public programs.
3. What the credit may offset
A credit can be limited to energy charges, or allowed to reduce fixed charges too. LG&E and KU’s NMS-2 credit “will be applied only to the energy charge and any riders that are based on a per kWh charge”, and the utilities’ page adds that credits “never offset non-energy charges on a bill (such as gas and basic service charges)”. At LG&E, the Rate RS basic service charge is $0.48 per day, which is $14.40 in a 30-day month ($0.48 x 30). At KU it is $0.58 per day, or $17.40 in 30 days. No quantity of solar credit reduces those amounts.
4. Carryover and true-up
Carryover decides what happens when credits exceed the charges they can offset. Kentucky’s riders carry unused credit forward from bill to bill, but credit “existing at the time Customer’s service is terminated” ends with the account, and LG&E and KU say credits never become cash and do not earn interest. California’s net metering tariffs settled once a year: at the 12-month true-up, surplus kWh were paid at “net surplus compensation”, which the CPUC puts at about $0.02 to $0.03 per kWh.
5. Charges you pay whatever you export
Some charges apply no matter how much you export. In California these are non-bypassable charges, which fund public purpose programs, Department of Water Resources bonds, nuclear decommissioning and competition transition charges. Under NEM 1.0 they were based on net annual consumption; under NEM 2.0, on net consumption in each hour; under net billing, on all imports. In Kentucky, the fixed daily basic service charge plays a similar role, and KRS 278.466(5) lets a utility seek rates that recover “fixed and demand-based costs” from customer-generators through a rate case.
How the netting interval changes the bill
The netting interval matters only when an exported kWh is worth less than an imported one. When both are priced at retail, it makes no difference to the energy charge whether kWh are netted every second or once a month. When exports earn less, every shortening of the interval turns more of your solar into low-value exports and more of your use into full-price imports.
The fictional day below shows the effect. It is not the site’s example home; it is a simpler household chosen to keep the arithmetic short.
Over the day, the panels produce 30.0 kWh and the house uses 28.0 kWh. Netted over the whole day, the home is a net exporter of 2.0 kWh. Netted hour by hour, the picture changes: the home exports 18.1 kWh between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m. and imports 16.1 kWh overnight, in the early morning and in the evening.
A meter that records every flow as it happens sees even more in both directions. Within an hour, a dryer cycle or a passing cloud can push the house into importing for a few minutes and exporting for the rest.
Example (fictional). Suppose the hour-by-hour totals are as shown above, and that flows inside individual hours add another 1.5 kWh in each direction, so a meter recording every flow sees 17.6 kWh imported and 19.6 kWh exported. Price everything at the site’s fictional flat rate of 13 cents per kWh, with a 7 cent export credit where exports are paid separately.
- Netted over the day, credited at retail: 30.0 kWh produced minus 28.0 kWh used leaves 2.0 kWh of credit to carry forward. Energy charge for the day: $0.00.
- Netted hourly, net billing: imports 16.1 kWh x $0.13 = $2.093; exports 18.1 kWh x $0.07 = $1.267. Net energy charge: $2.093 minus $1.267 = $0.826, about $0.83.
- Every flow counted, net billing: imports 17.6 kWh x $0.13 = $2.288; exports 19.6 kWh x $0.07 = $1.372. Net energy charge: $2.288 minus $1.372 = $0.916, about $0.92.
- Hourly or every flow, but credited at retail: 16.1 x $0.13 minus 18.1 x $0.13 = $2.093 minus $2.353, a credit of $0.26. The same as netting over the day, because both directions carry the same price.
Without solar, the same 28.0 kWh would cost 28.0 x $0.13 = $3.64. So the panels are worth $3.90 that day under retail crediting (30.0 kWh x $0.13, counting the carried credit), about $2.81 under hourly net billing ($3.64 minus $0.83) and about $2.72 when every flow is counted ($3.64 minus $0.92).
Three rules fall out of this example:
- With retail-valued credits, the interval barely matters for the energy charge. It matters for charges calculated on net consumption per interval, such as California’s non-bypassable charges under NEM 2.0.
- With a lower export credit, the interval decides how much solar counts as export. Shorter intervals mean more exports and more imports, each priced against you.
- Under net billing, the timing of household use is worth money. Moving a load from the evening into a sunny hour turns an export into self-consumption, worth the gap between the retail price and the credit: 6 cents per kWh at 13 and 7 cents.
To run your own month both ways, the net metering credit calculator takes the kWh you bought, the kWh you exported, your retail price and your export credit. Its default example, a fictional month with 600 kWh bought and 380 kWh exported at 13 and 7 cents, shows an energy charge of $28.60 under net metering and $51.40 under net billing.
California’s net billing tariff: export prices that change by the hour
California has replaced its net metering rules twice since 1996, which makes its three tariffs a useful reference. The CPUC created NEM 1.0 in 1996 under SB 656 and NEM 2.0 in 2016 under AB 327. On December 15, 2022 it adopted decision D.22-12-056, which established the Net Billing Tariff “as a successor to NEM2”, and the tariff applies to customers who submit an interconnection application on or after April 15, 2023, according to the CPUC’s net billing tariff page. The large utilities call it the “Solar Billing Plan”.
The key change is the credit rate. Under NEM 1.0 and 2.0, exports were credited at the customer’s import rates. Under net billing, exports earn values from the CPUC’s Avoided Cost Calculator, which the CPUC describes as “usually lower than import rates” but able to “rise above the retail rate on late summer evenings”.
| Setting | NEM 1.0 | NEM 2.0 | Net billing tariff |
|---|---|---|---|
| Import rate schedule | Any | Time-of-use rates | Specific "electrification" time-of-use rates |
| Credit for exports before true-up | Import rates | Import rates | Avoided Cost Calculator values, usually lower than import rates |
| Credit for net surplus at true-up | Wholesale price of energy | Wholesale price of energy | Wholesale price of energy |
| Non-bypassable charges based on | Net energy consumed in a year | Net energy consumed in each metered interval (1 hour for residential) | All energy imports |
| Interconnection fee | None | $94 to $145 | $94 to $145 |
| Billing and true-up | Annual billing, annual true-up | Annual billing, annual true-up | Monthly billing; credits roll over to an annual true-up |
How California prices an exported kWh
Southern California Edison’s export pricing page shows how fine-grained the prices are. Each year, SCE calculates its Energy Export Credit prices from the Avoided Cost Calculator approved as of January 1. A simple average price is set for each month, “differentiated by hour (24 hours) and by weekdays and weekend/holidays”. That is 24 hours x 2 day types x 12 months, or 576 export prices in a year, each applied to the kWh exported in that slot.
Those prices are locked by “vintage”. A customer who applied in a given year keeps that year’s price set for 9 years from the start of service, after which the prices may change. The CPUC page adds four other features of the tariff:
- An export adder. Residential PG&E and SCE customers who apply to interconnect before the end of 2027 receive slightly higher export credits for nine years. SDG&E customers and homes that must add solar under the building code do not receive it.
- A required rate. Customers must take a specific “electrification” time-of-use rate: E-ELEC at PG&E, TOU-D-PRIME at SCE and EV-TOU-5 at SDG&E.
- A nine-year legacy period for the original customer who interconnects the system.
- Monthly billing, so charges are paid as they come, while excess credits roll over until the annual true-up.
What California homeowners did
The CPUC reports that “nearly 70 percent” of net billing customers paired batteries with their solar by the end of 2024. That is the predictable response to a low daytime export price and a high evening import price. What to do with a system under rules like these is the subject of a companion article, solar exports after NEM 3.0.
Kentucky’s NMS-2: a flat dollar credit called net metering
Kentucky shows why the label is unreliable. KRS 278.465(4) defines “net metering” as the difference between the dollar value of electricity a customer-generator feeds back to the grid over a billing period, priced as the Public Service Commission (PSC) prescribes, and the dollar value of electricity the customer consumes over the same period, priced under the utility’s tariff. By the definitions at the top of this article, that is net billing.
The statute, KRS 278.466, fills in the rest. The PSC sets the compensation rate through ratemaking; compensation is “a dollar-denominated bill credit” each billing period; excess credit carries forward to the next bill; and no cash refund is paid when an account closes. Systems that were in service before the PSC’s first compensation order keep their old terms, including the one-to-one kWh credit, for 25 years at those premises, even if the home is sold.
How NMS-2 works at LG&E and KU
At LG&E and KU, that produces Rider NMS-2 (tariff Sheet No. 58, effective February 16, 2026). It applies to customer-owned solar, wind, biomass, biogas or hydro systems up to 45 kW that first reached in-service status on or after September 24, 2021. The sheet reads:
Company will (a) bill Customer for all energy consumed from Company in accordance with Customer’s standard rate and (b) Company will provide a dollar denominated bill credit for each kWh Customer produces to the Company’s grid.
In terms of the five settings:
| Setting | NMS-2 at LG&E and KU |
|---|---|
| Netting interval | None for kWh: the meter records flows in each direction; the dollar amounts are netted over the billing period |
| Credit rate | $0.07089 per exported kWh at LG&E, $0.07534 at KU |
| What the credit offsets | Only the energy charge and riders billed per kWh |
| Carryover | Carried forward bill to bill; ends with the account; no cash |
| Charges paid regardless | The daily basic service charge ($0.48 at LG&E, $0.58 at KU on Rate RS) and riders not billed per kWh |
The sheet also protects the shape of the bill. A customer who starts NMS-2 on a standard rate with a “two-part rate structure”, which Rate RS is (a daily basic service charge plus an energy charge per kWh), may stay on a two-part structure for 25 years from the date NMS-2 service began. That matters because KRS 278.466(5) allows a utility to propose rates that recover fixed and demand-based costs from customer-generators, for example through a demand charge measured in kW.
The billing-period netting was a deliberate choice. In its September 24, 2021 order in Cases 2020-00349 and 2020-00350, the PSC rejected what it called LG&E and KU’s “proposed instantaneous credit for all energy exported” as inconsistent with KRS 278.465(4). It required the utilities to net the total energy consumed and exported over the billing period, with the energy charge and per-kWh riders netted against exports.
The gap between price and credit
The Rate RS energy charge is $0.11499 per kWh at LG&E and $0.11396 at KU (Sheet No. 5, effective September 1, 2026; base charges before riders and taxes). So at LG&E a kWh used at home is worth $0.11499 and a kWh exported $0.07089, a gap of 4.41 cents and a ratio of about 1.6 to 1 ($0.11499 divided by $0.07089 = 1.62). At KU the gap is 3.86 cents and the ratio about 1.5 to 1 ($0.11396 divided by $0.07534 = 1.51).
The PSC built the credit from avoided-cost components such as energy, generation capacity, transmission and distribution capacity, carbon cost and environmental compliance. How those components were set, how NMS-1 differs, and what the numbers mean for a Kentucky solar decision are covered in detail in Kentucky net metering in 2026.
Is net metering always one-for-one with retail?
No. Many explainers say net metering credits every exported kWh at the full retail price, but real net metering tariffs carry limits that can lower the value of exports well before a state moves to net billing. Five are common, and the tariffs above show each one.
| Limit | Where it appears | What it does to an exported kWh |
|---|---|---|
| Credits stay in their time block | LG&E and KU NMS-1 on a time-of-day rate | A kWh exported off-peak can offset only off-peak use, never on-peak use |
| Annual true-up at a low price | California NEM 1.0 and NEM 2.0 | Surplus left at the true-up earns about 2 to 3 cents, not retail |
| Charges on each hour’s net use | California NEM 2.0 non-bypassable charges | Exports in one hour cannot offset these charges on imports in another |
| Credits limited to energy charges | LG&E and KU NMS-1 and NMS-2 | Credits never reduce the basic service charge |
| Credits end with the account | Kentucky riders and KRS 278.466(4) | Banked credit is lost on closing or moving, with no cash refund |
The first limit deserves a closer look because it is easy to miss. LG&E’s NMS-1 sheet (Sheet No. 57) says that on a time-of-use or time-of-day rate, credits created “in a particular time-of-day or time-of-use block” offset consumption “only” in that same block. A summer afternoon export on an on-peak block offsets on-peak use; a weekend export, which falls in the off-peak block, cannot.
Two billing practices can also make credits look smaller than they are. LG&E and KU note that budget billing levels payments across the seasons, which can hide summer solar savings, and that an estimated bill can understate generation credits until the net meter is actually read. Neither changes the credit rate; both change what a single month’s bill appears to show.
Legacy terms also expire. LG&E and KU will end NMS-1 on September 24, 2046 and move those customers to NMS-2. California’s NEM 2.0 customers may stay on that tariff for 20 years from interconnection under D.14-03-041. A home bought with an older system carries a clock that a buyer should read.
Why the gap between retail price and export credit drives every solar decision
Once you know the retail price and the export credit, you know the value of moving one kWh of solar from export to home use. It is the difference between the two. Under kWh-for-kWh net metering on a flat rate, that difference is close to zero; under net billing, it is the main lever a household controls.
| Design and prices | Value of a kWh used at home | Value of a kWh exported | Gain from using instead of exporting |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net metering, fictional flat 13 cents | $0.13 | $0.13 | $0.00 |
| Net billing, fictional 13 cents and 7 cent credit | $0.13 | $0.07 | $0.06 |
| LG&E NMS-2, Rate RS, base energy charge | $0.11499 | $0.07089 | $0.0441 |
| KU NMS-2, Rate RS, base energy charge | $0.11396 | $0.07534 | $0.03862 |
The rows marked fictional use the site’s example rate, not a tariff. The Kentucky rows use the September 1, 2026 energy charges and the February 16, 2026 credits, before riders and taxes.
Self-consumption: the cheapest way to use the gap
Self-consumption is the share of your solar used at home, directly or through a battery, instead of exported. Under net billing, raising it is worth the gap on every kWh you move. Loads that can run in sunny hours are the easiest place to start: a heat pump water heater heating its tank at midday, a dishwasher or laundry on a delay timer, a pool pump, pre-cooling the house before a summer evening, and EV charging on days the car is home.
The solar self-consumption calculator runs this arithmetic for a month. Its default example is fictional: 900 kWh of solar, 40% used at home, a 13 cent retail price and a 7 cent credit. Raising the self-used share to 60% moves 180 kWh from export to home use (20% of 900), worth 180 x $0.06 = $10.80 a month.
Batteries: when storing beats exporting
A battery loses energy on the way in and out. The National Renewable Energy Laboratory’s Annual Technology Baseline 2024 adopts 85% as a representative round-trip efficiency for residential batteries, so storing 1 kWh of surplus returns about 0.85 kWh later. Storing pays when 0.85 times the price of the hour the energy replaces is more than the export credit.
Example (fictional). Using the site’s example rate, which is not a utility tariff:
- Net metering at a flat 13 cents: storing 1 kWh returns 0.85 kWh worth 0.85 x $0.13 = $0.1105. Exporting it earns $0.13. Storing loses $0.0195, about 2 cents per kWh.
- Net billing at 13 cents with a 7 cent credit: storing returns $0.1105; exporting earns $0.07. Storing gains $0.0405, about 4 cents per kWh.
- Net billing with a 31 cent evening peak: storing returns 0.85 x $0.31 = $0.2635; exporting earns $0.07. Storing gains $0.1935, about 19 cents per kWh.
The same battery that loses money on solar shifting under flat-rate net metering earns on every stored kWh under net billing, and earns most when the evening price is high.
The site’s fictional example home shows a related point on a time-of-day example rate. With a schedule, its battery holds solar through the afternoon and covers the house from 5 to 9 p.m.; the day’s exports rise from 12.7 kWh to 15.9 kWh, yet the net cost for that one clear April weekday falls from $2.52 to $0.60. The value came from which hours the stored energy replaced, not from exporting less. One spring day is not a month or a year, and cloudy days, winter and weekends change the result.
How to find the five settings for your own home
Your bill shows the results; your tariff shows the rules. Work from your utility’s published tariff or the copy filed with your state utility commission, with a recent bill in hand.
- Find your rate schedule and your net metering rider. Search your utility’s site for “tariff” or “rate schedules”, or your state commission’s tariff library. The rider is often a separate sheet, such as Sheet No. 58 for NMS-2 at LG&E and KU.
- Find your eligibility date. Older tariffs usually stay open to systems in service before a cutoff. In Kentucky the cutoff is September 24, 2021; in California, interconnection applications on or after April 15, 2023 go to net billing.
- Identify the netting interval. Look for words such as “billing period”, “metered interval”, “hourly” or “for each kWh”. Check how your meter records flows: the interconnection guidelines at LG&E call for metering “capable of registering power flow in both directions for each time period defined by the applicable rate schedule”.
- Read the credit rate. Note whether it is kWh-for-kWh, a dollar figure per kWh or a price table, and its effective date.
- Read what the credit may offset. Energy charges only, per-kWh riders, or fixed charges as well.
- Read the carryover and true-up terms. When credits expire, whether they pay out, and at what price.
- List the charges you pay regardless. Basic service charges, non-bypassable charges, minimum bills and any charges specific to customer-generators.
- Match the bill lines. Find the kWh delivered to you and the kWh received from you. Utilities label them differently, for example “delivered” and “received”. The utility bill checklist lists what else to find on the bill and the schedule.
- Watch for changes. Export credits change through rate cases and commission orders. The NC Clean Energy Technology Center publishes The 50 States of Solar, a quarterly review of state actions on net metering and rate design with links to primary sources; its executive summaries are free and full reports become free after a year.
Sizing, orientation and loads under each design
The crediting design changes which planning choices pay. Under net metering, the year’s total production is what counts, and a kWh produced in May can offset a kWh used in January if the tariff carries kWh across months. Under net billing, the hour of production and the hour of use both count.
| Decision | Under kWh-for-kWh net metering | Under net billing |
|---|---|---|
| System size | Often sized to cover annual use, since surplus kWh offset later purchases | Value per kWh falls once production exceeds what the house uses in sunny hours |
| Panel orientation | Total annual kWh matters most | Output in hours with high import prices or high export prices can matter more than total kWh |
| Battery | Mostly backup, or arbitrage on a time-of-use rate | Moves surplus into evening hours; value grows with the gap between evening price and export credit |
| Water heater, pool pump, laundry | Timing matters only on a time-of-use rate | Running them in sunny hours turns exports into self-consumption |
| EV charging | Cheapest off-peak window, solar or not | Midday charging on days the car is home can beat both export and overnight charging, depending on the rate |
| Moving house | Legacy terms may transfer with the premises | Check whether the credit, any adder and any lock-in period transfer |
None of these rules is universal; each depends on the actual prices in your tariff. Charging the car from midday solar costs the export credit you give up; charging overnight costs the off-peak price. A home on net billing whose overnight price is below its export credit may therefore do better exporting at midday and charging overnight. The arithmetic belongs to the rate, not to a rule of thumb.
Questions to put to a solar proposal
A quote’s savings estimate is only as good as the crediting rules inside it. Before comparing proposals, ask each installer to state:
- Which tariff and rider the estimate assumes, with its sheet number and effective date.
- How many kWh a year the model treats as used at home and how many as exported, and the price applied to each.
- Whether exports are valued at retail, at a fixed credit or at hourly prices, and how the estimate handles a true-up or expiring credits.
- Whether fixed charges, such as a daily basic service charge, are left out of the savings, as they should be when credits cannot offset them.
The solar homes page covers what a schedule can do before a battery is added. If your utility offers both a time-of-use plan and a flat plan alongside its net metering rider, the choice of rate interacts with the export credit, which is explained in how time-of-use rates work.
What to do next
Start with your own tariff and a full year of bills, then put numbers on the gap. A short checklist:
- Note your net metering or net billing rider by name and sheet number, and its effective date.
- Write down your eligibility date and any legacy period, with its end date.
- Record the netting interval, the credit rate and what the credit may offset.
- Record the carryover and true-up rules, and whether credits ever pay out.
- Compute the gap: your retail energy price minus your export credit.
- Run one month through the net metering credit calculator and one through the solar self-consumption calculator.
- List the loads you could move into sunny hours, and their kW and run times.
- If you have or are pricing a battery, compare 0.85 times your evening price with your export credit.
Culni, the Louisville software company that publishes Rate Notes, builds a daily schedule for solar, batteries, EV charging and flexible loads from a home’s rate, including its export credit. Its solar export page explains how that schedule ranks using, storing and exporting each kWh, and how it works lists what you send and what comes back. If you want a written home energy plan for your own tariff, the contact page says what to include. Tariffs and commission orders change, so recheck the sheets and dates above before you rely on them.
