Culni homeCheck my home
Menu

How to schedule a heat pump water heater for time-of-use rates

Heat pump water heater time of use settings: which mode to pick, how far to load up before a peak, and summer and winter schedules that keep showers hot.

Reader question
How should I set a heat pump water heater's mode, temperature and schedule so it heats in cheap hours without running out of hot water?
A domed brick bread oven whose fire has burned down to a few embers, with round loaves baking on the hearth in the stored heat.

Run the water heater in heat pump only mode, keep the setpoint at 120°F unless a thermostatic mixing valve is installed, and schedule it to finish heating just before each peak window and stay off until the window ends. The tank then coasts through the peak on stored hot water and reheats with the compressor once prices drop. The mode matters as much as the clock: in hybrid or high demand modes the 4,500-watt resistance elements tend to switch on at the start of a load-up or right after a peak, and one element run in peak hours can cost more than the whole shift saves.

This guide draws on Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) tests, a California utility pilot, one manufacturer’s documents and federal scald guidance, then builds summer and winter schedules on LG&E’s Residential Time-of-Day Energy rate in Kentucky, with the arithmetic shown.

What a water heater tank can store and shift

A water heater tank is a thermal battery: you put heat in during cheap hours and draw it out as hot water later. The amount it holds is set by three numbers you can read off your own equipment: the tank’s rated gallons, the setpoint and the temperature of the cold water coming in.

Water takes 1 Btu per pound per degree Fahrenheit, a gallon weighs about 8.34 pounds, and 1 kWh equals 3,412 Btu. A tank rated at 45 gallons (the rated capacity of a typical 50-gallon nominal model) therefore holds about 375 Btu, or 0.11 kWh of heat, for every degree it is warmed. Raising that tank by 15°F stores about 5,630 Btu, or 1.65 kWh of heat.

That matches what researchers measured. In laboratory tests published by PNNL and the University of Central Florida, a prototype heat pump water heater using the newer CTA-2045-B control standard raised its tank 15°F above setpoint on command and stored about 1.8 kWh in a 50-gallon tank. The same work found that grid-connected heat pump water heaters cut peak demand by as much as 0.5 kW, with the result depending on tank volume, time of day, control scheme and how the household drew water (OSTI record 1922486).

Why the numbers stay small

Heat pump water heaters use little electricity to begin with. The same PNNL work reports that they cut water heating energy by more than 65% compared with electric resistance water heaters. In a California pilot that controlled real heat pump water heaters every day, the uncontrolled units in the comparison group used about 3.1 to 4.0 kWh a day (ACEEE 2024 Summer Study paper).

So a schedule moves only a modest number of kWh each day. What it can do reliably is keep the resistance elements out of the most expensive hours, which is where most of the money is, as the worked examples below show.

Water heaters already lean off-peak

The heater does not always reheat at the moment water is drawn. In modeled California data shown at an ENERGY STAR partner meeting in October 2020, 29% of hot water draws fell in a 5 to 9 p.m. peak, but an uncontrolled heat pump water heater used only 14% of its energy in those hours, and 1% with load shifting.

Heat pump, hybrid, high demand or electric: which mode to use

Use heat pump only mode for time-of-use scheduling whenever the tank is big enough for your household, and switch to a hybrid mode only on days when you expect unusually heavy use. Hybrid and high demand modes bring in the resistance elements when the tank temperature falls far below setpoint, which is exactly what happens at the start of a load-up and right after a peak.

Manufacturers name the modes differently. ENERGY STAR notes that heat pump water heaters are also commonly called hybrid electric water heaters, because most have both a compressor and resistance elements. Rheem’s operating modes article (May 29, 2025) is one published example. Its default Energy Saver mode activates the upper element only “when necessary”; Heat Pump mode keeps the elements off, with recovery that can take 2 to 10 hours depending on air and inlet water temperatures; High Demand runs an element alongside the heat pump; Electric mode is recommended only when the surrounding air drops below 37°F and reverts to Energy Saver after 72 hours; and Vacation drops the setpoint to 65°F for 2 to 28 days.

Mode (names vary by maker)Resistance elementsWhen it fitsEffect on a time-of-use schedule
Heat pump onlyOffNormal days, when the tank covers the household's drawsBest fit. Slow recovery, so load-up windows must start earlier
Energy saver or hybrid (often the default)Upper element when the tank falls well below setpointHouseholds that sometimes run shortElements tend to fire at the start of load-up and after a peak
High demandRun together with the compressorGuests, holidays, very cold inlet waterMost element use; avoid during or just after peak windows
ElectricOnly heat sourceAir around the unit below the compressor's range, or a compressor faultRoughly ten times the compressor's power draw; schedule strictly off-peak
Vacation or awayOff at a low setpointAbsences of several daysLittle use in any window; schedule a load-up before you return
Mode descriptions from Rheem's operating modes article (May 29, 2025) and the ACEEE 2024 Summer Study paper on PG&E's WatterSaver pilot; the ten-times figure is the paper's 4,500 W versus 400 W comparison. Other manufacturers' modes behave similarly but not identically; check your owner's manual.

What the field data show about hybrid mode

The clearest evidence comes from WatterSaver, a Pacific Gas and Electric pilot that has sent daily load-up and shed commands to enrolled water heaters since March 2022. A 2024 paper by the program’s implementers at the Association for Energy Affordability and PG&E reports how often the elements came on, broken out by the mode each household had chosen (ACEEE 2024).

For the manufacturer with measured power data, Heat Pump mode was the least likely to trigger the resistance elements, High Demand the most likely, and Hybrid in between. Element use jumped at two moments: at the start of a load-up that raised the setpoint, and at the start of recovery after the shed period ended. The authors note that even though these instances were few, they mattered because the element’s power draw is “an order of magnitude higher,” 4,500 W against about 400 W for the compressor.

The same paper lists the power values that connected water heaters report: 356 to 800 W with the compressor running, 4,500 to 5,500 W with an element running.

When heat pump only mode is the wrong choice

Recovery in heat pump only mode is slow, so back-to-back showers or a large tub can run the tank short. If that happens often, the fix is usually more storage (a bigger tank, or a mixing valve so the tank can be stored hotter), not a mode that lets the elements run whenever the tank dips. The WatterSaver authors recommend the same: size for storage so the heater can run at 120°F in heat pump only mode.

Electric mode is for real limits, not convenience. ENERGY STAR advises installing heat pump water heaters in interior spaces that stay between 40°F and 90°F year-round, with about 1,000 cubic feet of air around the unit, and notes that in cold months a unit may need to switch temporarily to its backup electric mode, which increases energy use.

How long the compressor needs: sizing the load-up window

Plan on about 1.5 to 2 hours of compressor time to top up a partly drawn tank before a peak, and more if the heater sits in a cool space. A heat pump water heater heats slowly because the compressor delivers far less heat per hour than a resistance element.

The Rheem ProTerra specification sheet gives the numbers for one product line. Its 50-gallon model has a rated capacity of 45 gallons, a uniform energy factor (UEF) of 3.88, a first hour rating of 67 gallons, a compressor output of 4,200 Btu per hour, a 4,500-watt element rated at 240 volts (3.375 kW at 208 volts) and a 30-amp breaker. For comparison, ENERGY STAR’s criteria for integrated heat pump water heaters call for a UEF of at least 3.30 and a first hour rating of at least 45 gallons.

Convert both heat sources to the same unit and the difference is plain:

Heat source Heat output Time to add 5,630 Btu (45 gallons, 15°F) Gallons heated per hour, 90°F rise
Compressor, 4,200 Btu per hour 1.23 kW of heat about 80 minutes about 5.6
One element, 4,500 W 4.5 kW of heat (15,355 Btu per hour) about 22 minutes about 20.5

The arithmetic: 4,200 Btu per hour divided by 3,412 is 1.23 kW. Heating one gallon by 90°F takes 8.34 x 90 = 751 Btu, so the compressor heats 4,200 / 751 = 5.6 gallons an hour and the element 15,355 / 751 = 20.5. Together that is about 26 gallons an hour, close to the 27 gallons per hour of recovery the spec sheet lists at a 90°F rise.

These are nameplate figures. Real recovery depends on the air around the unit and the incoming water temperature, which is why Rheem’s range for heat pump only recovery runs from 2 to 10 hours. Treat the 80 minutes as the fast end.

A rule of thumb for the load-up start time

Count back from the start of the peak by the time the compressor needs to replace a typical pre-peak draw, then add a margin. If the household usually draws 15 gallons in the hour before the peak, that is about 15 x 8.34 x 65 = 8,131 Btu at a 65°F rise from cold water at 55°F to a 120°F setpoint (hypothetical temperatures; your inlet water may be colder in winter). At 4,200 Btu per hour, that takes about 1.9 hours. Start the load-up 2 to 2.5 hours before the peak, and earlier if the heater sits in an unheated basement in winter.

If the tank is far below its target when a load-up begins, a hybrid mode heater may bring in an element, as the WatterSaver data show at the start of load-ups that raised the setpoint.

Loading up before a peak: setpoint, mixing valves and scald limits

A basic load-up brings the tank to its normal setpoint just before the peak, and that is safe at any setpoint you already use. An advanced load-up heats the tank above its normal setpoint to store more energy, and it should only be done with a thermostatic mixing valve that tempers the water leaving the tank.

What the scald guidance says

The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission urges households to lower water heaters to 120°F. Its guidance gives the exposure times for third-degree burns in most adults: two seconds at 150°F, six seconds at 140°F, thirty seconds at 130°F, and five minutes even at 120°F. The same document notes that most tap water scald injuries and deaths involve older adults and children under five.

That is why the WatterSaver pilot only raised tanks to 140°F for participants who had a thermostatic mixing valve installed; households without one received basic load-up commands only. The PNNL prototype that stored an extra 15°F had a mixing valve built in to meet anti-scald codes. The Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance (NEEA) advises installers to fit a larger tank and add a thermal mixing valve where possible when a heater will be used for load shifting.

Adding a mixing valve is plumbing work. Local plumbing code and a licensed plumber decide the valve type, its location and the delivered temperature setting.

How much extra hot water a hotter tank gives

A mixing valve blends tank water with cold water to deliver a fixed temperature, so a hotter tank stretches further. The share of tank water in each gallon delivered is (delivered temperature minus inlet temperature) divided by (tank temperature minus inlet temperature).

Example (fictional). A 45-gallon tank, cold water at 55°F, water delivered at 120°F through a mixing valve.

  • Tank at 120°F: each gallon delivered is all tank water, so the tank gives about 45 gallons at 120°F.
  • Tank at 135°F: (120 - 55) / (135 - 55) = 65 / 80 = 0.81 gallons of tank water per gallon delivered, so 45 / 0.8125 = about 55 gallons at 120°F.
  • Tank at 140°F: 65 / 85 = 0.765, so 45 / 0.765 = about 59 gallons at 120°F.

Raising the tank 15°F, from 120°F to 135°F, adds about 10 gallons of usable hot water and about 1.65 kWh of stored heat. In a real tank, cold water entering at the bottom mixes with some of the hot water, so both figures are upper bounds.

The cost of storing heat at a higher temperature

Storing hotter costs energy. The WatterSaver paper explains that a higher setpoint lowers the heat pump’s coefficient of performance (the heat it moves per unit of electricity) and raises standby losses through the tank walls. The pilot’s households with setpoints at or above 140°F used about 30% more energy per day than those set lower, by the paper’s count, though the authors note that part of the gap may come from heavier hot water use.

The advanced load-up group showed the trade clearly. Compared with its own control days, it used 0.50 kWh less from 4 to 9 p.m., used 0.64 kWh more during the 2 to 4 p.m. load-up, and ended the day roughly even, 3.49 kWh against 3.48 kWh. On a rate with a wide gap between peak and off-peak prices, that trade pays. On a rate with a narrow gap, it does not, which is why the authors are working to make advanced load-up energy neutral.

Coasting through the peak without running out

During the peak the heater should stay off unless the tank falls low enough to risk a cold shower. In program language this is a “shed.” In the WatterSaver pilot, a shed sent through the manufacturer’s own interface lowered the setpoint by 10°F, never below 110°F, and still allowed the heater to recover if the tank fell below that floor.

That floor is a good model for a home schedule. Do not set the heater fully off for the peak. Lower the setpoint instead, so the heater stays idle while the tank still has useful hot water and reheats only if it runs low.

How to check that the tank lasts

Compare the hot water your household draws during the peak window with the usable hot water in the tank at the start of it. The usable volume is the tank’s rated gallons at its setpoint, adjusted with the mixing formula above if you have a valve, less a margin for the mixing of cold water at the bottom.

  1. Write down when showers, baths, the dishwasher and laundry run on a typical weekday.
  2. Estimate the gallons in each peak window. A shower’s volume is its flow rate in gallons per minute times its minutes; the rate is often printed on the showerhead.
  3. Compare the peak-window total with about three quarters of the usable volume to allow for mixing. If the draws are larger, move a load of laundry or the dishwasher out of the window, or raise stored temperature with a mixing valve.

The rebound after the peak

When the shed ends, the heater sees a tank well below setpoint and starts recovering. This is the second element spike in the WatterSaver data: households in Hybrid and High Demand modes saw the elements fire at the start of post-shed recovery. In the group with setpoints below 140°F, the share of measured instances with an element running rose from 0.6% in ordinary hours to 7% at that moment.

You can avoid it in two ways. Keep the heater in heat pump only mode for a few hours after each peak, or set the post-peak setpoint to return in two steps rather than one. The first option is simpler, and some apps let you schedule a mode as well as a temperature.

A summer schedule for an afternoon peak

On a summer rate with one afternoon peak, the schedule is simple: load up in the late morning, coast through the peak, and recover in the evening when most showers happen anyway. The worked case below uses LG&E’s Residential Time-of-Day Energy rate (RTOD-Energy) in Louisville, Kentucky. See the LG&E and KU time-of-day guide for whether that rate suits a household, and the general time-of-use explainer for how rating periods and price ratios work.

The windows and prices

LG&E’s tariff sets the rating periods in Eastern Standard Time all year (Sheet No. 6.1). From April through October, weekday on-peak hours are 1 to 5 p.m. EST, which the utility’s time-of-day page shows as 2 to 6 p.m. on daylight-saving clocks. Weekends are off-peak all day, and a legal holiday on a weekday counts as a weekday.

The energy charges on Sheet No. 6, effective September 1, 2026, are $0.19307 per kWh on-peak and $0.09312 per kWh off-peak, base charges before riders and taxes. The gap is $0.09995 per kWh. For comparison, the standard residential Rate RS energy charge on Sheet No. 5 is $0.11499 per kWh at any hour. The rate requires an AMI meter and is limited to 500 customers across RTOD-Energy and RTOD-Demand combined.

The schedule, in clock time

Clock time (summer weekday) Water heater setting Why
Midnight to 11:30 a.m. Heat pump only, normal setpoint Off-peak; morning showers recover at the off-peak price
11:30 a.m. to 2 p.m. Load up: reach setpoint (or a higher stored temperature with a mixing valve) Finishes heating before the peak
2 to 6 p.m. Shed: setpoint lowered about 10°F, floor at 110°F Peak window; tank coasts
6 to 9 p.m. Heat pump only, normal setpoint Off-peak recovery; avoids the element spike
9 p.m. to midnight Normal mode Off-peak

The summer case is usually the easy one. In many households little hot water is drawn between 2 and 6 p.m. on a weekday, so the tank coasts with plenty left; check your own draw times.

Example water heater schedules against LG&E RTOD-Energy weekday windowsTwo 24-hour timelines in clock time. Summer weekday: on-peak 2 to 6 p.m.; the water heater loads up from 11:30 a.m. to 2 p.m., coasts through the peak and heats with the heat pump after 6 p.m. Winter weekday: on-peak 6 to 10 a.m. and 6 to 10 p.m.; the water heater loads up from 3:30 to 6 a.m. and from 3:30 to 6 p.m., coasts through both peaks, and reheats with the heat pump from 10 a.m. and after 10 p.m.Summer weekday, April to October (daylight-time clock)RateHeaterWinter weekday, November to March (standard-time clock)RateHeater12 a.m.6 a.m.Noon6 p.m.12 a.m.Off-peakOn-peakLoad upCoast (setpoint lowered)Heat pump only, heating as needed
Example (fictional) schedules. Rate windows: LG&E Rate RTOD-Energy, Sheet No. 6.1, rating periods in Eastern Standard Time, shown in clock time as on the LG&E and KU time-of-day page; both checked November 2026. In the March and November transition weeks the winter windows fall one hour later on the clock, 7 to 11 a.m. and 7 to 11 p.m.

What the summer schedule is worth

Example (fictional). A 50-gallon (45 gallons rated) heat pump water heater on LG&E RTOD-Energy, a summer weekday. A dishwasher and a load of laundry at 2:30 p.m. clock time draw 15 gallons. Cold water enters at 55°F and the setpoint is 120°F, so refilling those 15 gallons takes 15 x 8.34 x 65 = 8,131 Btu, or 2.38 kWh of heat. Assume the compressor draws 0.5 kW while it delivers its nameplate 1.23 kW of heat (0.5 kW is within the 356 to 800 W range the WatterSaver paper reports).

  • Default, energy saver mode, no schedule. The tank calls for heat at 2:40 p.m., in the peak. The upper element runs 15 minutes: 4.5 kW x 0.25 hours = 1.125 kWh. The compressor supplies the remaining 2.38 - 1.125 = 1.26 kWh of heat in about one hour, drawing 0.5 kWh. Peak energy: 1.625 kWh x $0.19307 = $0.31.
  • Heat pump only mode, same timing. The compressor supplies all 2.38 kWh of heat in 2.38 / 1.23 = 1.93 hours, drawing 1.93 x 0.5 = 0.97 kWh, all in the peak: 0.97 x $0.19307 = $0.19.
  • Heat pump only mode with a shed until 6 p.m. The tank coasts; the compressor recovers after 6 p.m. off-peak: 0.97 kWh x $0.09312 = $0.09.

The first and last cases differ by about 22 cents: roughly 13 cents from the mode change (1.625 kWh against 0.97 kWh in the peak) and 10 cents from the timing (0.97 kWh x $0.09995). Over 20 weekdays with a draw like this, that is about $4.50, before riders and taxes.

The example shows the pattern the field data suggest. Moving compressor energy from peak to off-peak saves about 10 cents per kWh on this rate, but keeping the element off saves energy as well as money, because the element turns each kWh into one kWh of heat while the compressor moves two or more.

A winter schedule for morning and evening peaks

Winter is the hard case, because the peaks and the household’s hot water draws land on the same hours. From November through March, LG&E’s weekday on-peak hours are 6 to 10 a.m. and 6 to 10 p.m. EST, with off-peak from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. and from 10 p.m. to 6 a.m. (Sheet No. 6.1). Morning showers fall in the first peak and evening dishes and baths in the second.

The schedule needs two load-ups and two sheds, and the tank has to carry the morning draw by itself:

Clock time (winter weekday, standard time) Water heater setting Why
10 p.m. to 3:30 a.m. Heat pump only, normal setpoint Off-peak recovery from the evening
3:30 to 6 a.m. Load up: setpoint, or stored hotter with a mixing valve Tank full before showers start
6 to 10 a.m. Shed: setpoint lowered, floor at 110°F Morning peak; showers draw from storage
10 a.m. to 3:30 p.m. Heat pump only, normal setpoint Long off-peak recovery for the morning draw
3:30 to 6 p.m. Load up Tank full before the evening peak
6 to 10 p.m. Shed: setpoint lowered, floor at 110°F Evening peak; dishes and baths draw from storage

Example (fictional). The same 45-gallon tank with a mixing valve set to deliver 120°F, the tank stored at 130°F, and winter inlet water at 50°F. Two showers between 6:30 and 7:15 a.m. use 25 gallons at 120°F.

  • Usable storage at 6 a.m.: (120 - 50) / (130 - 50) = 70 / 80 = 0.875 gallons of tank water per gallon delivered, so up to 45 / 0.875 = 51 gallons at 120°F. The 25-gallon draw leaves a margin even after allowing for mixing in the tank.
  • Tank water replaced: 25 x 0.875 = 21.9 gallons. Reheating it from 50°F to 130°F takes 21.9 x 8.34 x 80 = 14,610 Btu, or 4.28 kWh of heat.
  • Scheduled (heat pump only, recovery from 10 a.m.): 4.28 / 1.23 = 3.5 hours of compressor time, done by about 1:30 p.m. Electricity at an assumed 0.5 kW: 1.74 kWh x $0.09312 = $0.16.
  • Unscheduled (hybrid mode, recovery at 7:15 a.m.): the element runs 30 minutes, 2.25 kWh, and the compressor supplies the remaining 2.03 kWh of heat in 1.65 hours at 0.83 kWh. Total 3.08 kWh x $0.19307 = $0.59, all in the peak.

The morning schedule saves $0.43 on this one draw, before riders and taxes. The load-up from 120°F to 130°F before 6 a.m. costs extra: 45 x 8.34 x 10 = 3,753 Btu, or 1.10 kWh of heat, about 0.45 kWh of electricity off-peak ($0.04), plus some added standby loss.

Winter conditions that shrink the margin

Three things work against a winter schedule: colder inlet water, so each gallon needs more heat; cooler air around a heater in a basement or garage, so the compressor delivers less heat per hour; and the heaviest draws of the day landing in the morning peak.

If the space around the heater falls below about 40°F, ENERGY STAR’s lower bound for installation, the heater may not be able to recover on the compressor alone. In that case, keep the schedule but move the element-heavy recovery into the 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. off-peak window, and talk to an installer about the location.

Weekends, holidays and the transition weeks

Weekends are off-peak all day on this rate, so the heater can run in heat pump only mode with no sheds. Weekday holidays count as weekdays. In the weeks when clocks are on daylight time but the winter windows still apply (from the second Sunday in March through March 31, and from November 1 to the first Saturday in November), LG&E’s page shows the peaks one hour later on the clock, 7 to 11 a.m. and 7 to 11 p.m. A heater app that runs on clock time needs its schedule moved for those weeks.

What CTA-2045 ports, apps and utility programs add

A connected heat pump water heater can follow a schedule in up to three ways: a timer or time-of-use setting in the heater’s own app, commands from a utility or aggregator through the CTA-2045 port or a manufacturer cloud connection, or a home energy schedule that sends the same kinds of commands. The behavior on the tank is the same in each case: load up, shed, and recover.

What CTA-2045 is

CTA-2045 is a standard for a modular demand response port on appliances. A PNNL presentation to DOE’s Better Buildings network notes it was first published in 2013, with ANSI/CTA-2045-B published in 2021, and that it lets a device connect to different demand response systems through a plug-in communication module (DOE Better Buildings slides, November 2024). A Bonneville Power Administration engineer described two module form factors, a low-voltage DC version and a 240-volt AC version, at the 2020 ENERGY STAR partner meeting. Some heaters ship with the port built in; Rheem’s spec sheet, for example, lists it as “Demand Response Ready with built-in EcoPort (CTA-2045 Port).”

Which commands a heater accepts depends on the version of the standard it supports. According to the table in the ACEEE 2024 paper:

CommandWhat it asks the heater to doVersions that support it
Basic load upHeat now, to the normal setpointAll versions
ShedAvoid heating until the event ends, unless the tank runs lowAll versions
Critical peakA more aggressive shedCTA-2045-A (March 2018), B level 1 and B level 2
Grid emergencyUse as little energy as possible, even at the risk of cold waterCTA-2045-A (March 2018), B level 1 and B level 2
Advanced load upHeat above the normal setpoint to store moreCTA-2045-B level 2 only, or a manufacturer's own interface
Command availability from Table 2 of the ACEEE 2024 Summer Study paper on PG&E's WatterSaver pilot; command descriptions summarized from the same paper. Each manufacturer defines its heater's exact response.

The standard does not specify exactly how a heater must respond, so behavior differs by manufacturer. The WatterSaver team dropped the grid emergency command because it raised the risk of cold-water events, and its authors call for the standard to become a conformance standard that defines each response.

Where the port is required

Washington State requires electric storage water heaters manufactured on or after January 1, 2021 and sold in the state to have a modular demand response communications port compliant with the March 2018 version of ANSI/CTA-2045-A. The same section bars a utility from altering a building’s water heater use based on data from the heater unless the customer has given written, affirmative consent to a program that allows it. NEEA’s 2024 slides state that Washington and Oregon require the ports on electric water heaters of 40 to 80 gallons.

Utility programs and their limits

NEEA reported a Bonneville Power Administration and Portland General Electric demonstration in which 278 water heaters were connected, most of the connections self-installed, and received 600 events over 270 days with “minimal to no complaints.” The WatterSaver pilot’s estimated bill effect for participants, on PG&E and SCE default time-of-use rates, ranged from $7 to $55 a year on average depending on the load-up strategy and rate, against average annual bills of about $1,600 to $2,000.

If you enroll a water heater in a utility program, its event commands take priority on event days and may not match your own rate windows, so compare the two before you enroll.

How a home energy schedule handles it

Culni is a home energy software company that reads a home’s electricity rate and runs one daily schedule across solar, a battery, EV charging and flexible loads such as a heat pump water heater. For a water heater, that means setting load-up and shed times from the tariff’s windows, choosing the mode for each part of the day, and checking the result against the monthly bill. Whether a particular heater can be reached, through its app’s cloud connection, a CTA-2045 module or not at all, is confirmed home by home; the device categories page explains how that check works. A heater that cannot connect stays on its own timer and is listed as manual.

How much money is at stake

For most households the dollars are modest, and the mode setting is worth more than the timing. On LG&E’s rate, moving 1 kWh of compressor energy from peak to off-peak saves about 10 cents before riders and taxes. One 30-minute element run in the peak costs about 43 cents (2.25 kWh x $0.19307), more than four times an hour of compressor operation in the same window.

Event, LG&E RTOD-Energy Electricity Cost on-peak Cost off-peak
Compressor, 1 hour at an assumed 0.5 kW 0.5 kWh $0.10 $0.05
One element, 30 minutes at 4.5 kW 2.25 kWh $0.43 $0.21
One element, 1 hour at 4.5 kW 4.5 kWh $0.87 $0.42
A whole day at 3.5 kWh (typical range in the pilot) 3.5 kWh $0.68 if all on-peak $0.33 if all off-peak

Energy charges only, base charges before riders and taxes, from LG&E Sheet No. 6 effective September 1, 2026.

The bottom row sets the ceiling: even if a whole day’s use moved from peak to off-peak, the saving would be about 35 cents on this rate, in line with the WatterSaver results of $7 to $55 a year. Scheduling is still worth doing because it costs little once set up, keeps the elements out of the peak and matters more on a wider price gap, but it will not move the bill the way an EV charging schedule can.

To test your own numbers, the appliance energy cost calculator turns watts and hours into kWh and cost by rate window. Its default example is a 5,000-watt load run one hour, 12 times a month: $18.60 a month at a fictional 31-cent peak price against $4.80 at an 8-cent off-peak price. That is close to the 5,000-watt total unit wattage on the Rheem spec sheet.

Where the heater fits in an all-electric home

In a home with a heat pump, an EV and perhaps a battery, the water heater is one of several loads that can move. Its load-up windows should not stack on top of an EV charging session or a heat pump’s pre-heating if the home is on a rate with a demand charge, and its morning shed overlaps the hours when a heat pump pre-heats or pre-cools the house. The all-electric homes page describes how those loads fit together on one schedule.

A settings checklist for your heater

Work through these steps once, then check the results after a week of normal use.

  1. Find your rate windows on your tariff sheet, noting standard time or clock time, weekends, holidays and seasons.
  2. Check the space around the heater. If it drops below about 40°F in winter, plan for slower recovery or ask an installer about ducting or relocation.
  3. Choose heat pump only mode for normal days; keep hybrid or high demand for heavy days and electric mode for a cold space or a failed compressor.
  4. Set 120°F unless a thermostatic mixing valve is installed and a licensed plumber has confirmed its delivered temperature.
  5. Start each load-up 2 to 2.5 hours before the peak, longer in winter or a cool space.
  6. Shed with a lower setpoint, not a shutoff: about 10°F lower, with a floor near 110°F.
  7. Keep heat pump only mode for a few hours after each peak.
  8. Move laundry and the dishwasher out of peak windows if the tank is small.
  9. Check after a week in the heater app or your smart meter data for element runs in peak hours and for anyone who ran short.
  10. Use vacation mode for absences, with a load-up before you return.

If you would rather have the windows, modes and load-ups worked out with your water heater, heat pump, EV and rate together, you can send your rate plan, a recent bill and your device list and ask for a written home energy plan.

TodayYour turn

Want this worked out for your home?

Send your utility and rate plan, one recent bill and the devices you have or plan. We reply with a written home energy plan and every assumption behind it.

Remote. No site visit needed.