Rate plan comparison calculator
Flat rate or time-of-use: the monthly energy cost of each, and the peak share where they break even.
- You enter
- Monthly kWh, flat price, usage shares, three TOU prices
- You get
- Monthly energy cost on each plan and the break-even
- Example rate
- Fictional: 13 cents flat; 31, 14 and 8 cents TOU
- Not covered
- Fixed charges, meter rules and enrollment limits

Calculator
Many utilities let a homeowner choose between a flat rate, with one energy price at every hour, and a time-of-use rate with cheap nights and an expensive peak. Which one costs less depends on when you use electricity, not only on how much. This calculator prices one month on both plans and finds the share of peak-hour use at which they cost the same.
What each input means and where to find it
| Input | What it means | Where to find it |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly electricity use | kWh bought in a billing period | The usage line on your bill |
| Flat-rate price | Energy charge per kWh on the flat plan | The rate schedule for the flat plan |
| Share of use in peak hours | Percentage of monthly use in the peak window | A time-of-use bill, or hourly data from your utility account |
| Share of use in off-peak hours | Percentage in the cheapest window; the rest counts as day hours | Same source |
| Time-of-use peak, day and off-peak prices | Energy charge per kWh in each window | The time-of-use rate schedule |
Use the same basis for both plans: either base energy charges on both, or base charges plus the same per-kWh riders on both. If the time-of-use rate has only two windows, enter its off-peak price in both the day and off-peak fields.
The formula in plain words
- Flat cost = monthly kWh × flat price.
- Time-of-use cost = monthly kWh × (peak share × peak price + day share × day price + off-peak share × off-peak price).
- Break-even peak share: keep your off-peak share as entered, move use between peak and day hours, and find the peak share at which the two costs match.
Example (fictional). The calculator opens with the fictional example rate: a 13 cent flat rate against a time-of-use rate of 31 cents at the peak, 14 cents in day hours and 8 cents off-peak. A home buys 900 kWh a month, 25% in peak hours and 45% off-peak, so 30% falls in day hours. The flat rate comes to $117.00 a month and time-of-use to $139.95, so time-of-use costs $22.95 more. The break-even peak share is 10% of use in peak hours: at 10%, both plans come to $117.00.
How to read the result
A positive difference means time-of-use costs more with your current habits; a negative one means it costs less. The break-even share is the number to aim at. If your peak share is already below it, time-of-use is cheaper without any change. If it is far above, reaching it takes real shifting: the car charging overnight, the water heater on a timer, or a battery covering the evening.
That is why the answer often flips once a schedule runs. On the example home’s clear April weekday, the Culni schedule brought the home’s purchases at the peak price to zero: it bought 21.0 kWh, 20.5 of them off-peak and 0.5 in day hours. One clear spring weekday is not a month, though. Cloudy days, winter peaks and weekends change the result, which is why a real plan models every day type.
Kentucky values to try
LG&E’s Rate RS charges $0.11499 per kWh. Its optional RTOD-Energy rate charges $0.19307 per kWh on-peak and $0.09312 off-peak. All three are base energy charges before riders and taxes, effective September 1, 2026 (tariff Sheets No. 5 and 6), and both plans carry the same $0.48 per day Basic Service Charge. RTOD-Energy has two windows, so enter $0.09312 as both the day and off-peak price. With 900 kWh and 25% of use at the peak, RTOD-Energy costs $2.81 more a month, and the break-even peak share is 22%.
Before you count on that rate, check eligibility. RTOD-Energy needs an AMI meter, is limited to 500 customers across RTOD-Energy and RTOD-Demand combined (first come, first served), and a customer who leaves for Rate RS cannot return for 12 months. Its windows are set in Eastern Standard Time all year: from April through October the weekday on-peak block is 1 to 5 p.m. standard time, which reads 2 to 6 p.m. on a summer clock. Weekends are off-peak. Culni is not affiliated with LG&E or KU.
Limits
- Energy charges only. If the plans have different daily or monthly charges, add the difference by hand.
- One month, one pattern. Peak windows and usage change by season; run a summer and a winter month.
- No demand charges. Rates that bill peak kW, such as RTOD-Demand, need a different calculation.
- Rate eligibility is the utility’s decision, including meter requirements and enrollment limits.
What to do next
Find the prices and windows for your own plans with the utility bill checklist, then see what moving use is worth with the time-of-use savings calculator. For Louisville homes, the Louisville and Kentucky page covers the local rates and net metering rules.
Culni’s rate engine decodes the rates you can choose from and compares them against your own usage, with and without a schedule. To get that comparison for your home, check my home.
TodayYour turn
Send your rate and your devices
Your utility and rate plan, one recent bill and the devices you have or plan. We reply with a written home energy plan: your rate decoded, which devices can connect, the daily schedule and its estimated value with every assumption shown.
Remote. No site visit needed.